Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Infidelity to the Constitution

Professors Goodwin Liu (Boalt Hall), Pamela Karlan (Stanford), and Christopher Schroeder (Duke) just published Keeping Faith with the Constitution, which they claim is a bold challenge to originalism (in all its stripes), on the one hand, and to "living constitutionalism," on the other, and a clear argument for a richer approach they call "constitutional fidelity." The book is one of a pair just released by the American Constitution Society. (The other is a collection of works on constitutional interpretation titled It is a Constitution We are Expounding.) You can download a full copy on the ACS site, here.

An announcement and commentary has been posted to the Constitutional Law Profs Blog.

My comments are as follows:

While the two books, especially Keeping Faith with the Constitution, seem sound at a certain level of abstraction, and claim to reject the "living Constitution" approach to constitutional construction, when they get to the details they largely embrace that approach, and accept what some historians would regard as departures from constitutional fidelity as better "understandings" of it. That is especially brought out in their treatment and acceptance of broad interpretation of the Commerce and Necessary and Proper clauses.

I bring out some of this in my article, Principles of Constitutional Construction, in which I point out that "strict" construction properly means narrow interpretation of government powers and broad interpretation of individual rights (or more precisely, immunities). As I also discuss in my article, Presumption of Nonauthority and Unenumerated Rights, there is a fundamental right to a presumption of nonauthority that invalidates such doctrines as deference to a legislature or to administrative agents.

The book seems to be a concession to the growing movement toward accepting some kind of originalism, but is actually a somewhat disingenuous recasting of the progressive agenda of the American Constitution Society into pseudo-originalist terms.

37 comments:

知道 said...

憂能傷身,保重哦!........................................

春天來嚕 said...

A truly happy person is one who can enjoy the scenery on a detour..............................................

淑君淑君 said...

嘟嘟貼圖電眼美女jp素人露出大全集人體藝術寫真夜店正妹正妹強正妹報時正妹圖片av999免費影片250av女優免費影片星野亞溪星野亞桌布春天貼圖網春天貼圖情色網春天吶喊比基尼辣妹時尚男女聊天室景美女中前女友自拍景美女中自拍女學生時間停止器短片 線上觀看時間計時器美女 視訊美女 視訊視訊交友fireup日本a片免費下載xx369色女人專用愛愛一葉情貼影色站露點girl532085cc成人片觀看一夜聊天室免費a片77p2p成人文章一葉情貼圖片區影音視訊聊天777美女dvd影片777美女dvd小魔女影城免費成人聊天室免費影音下載hibb美眉共和國美女短片免費試看色美媚部落格

于名于倫 said...

無一事而不學,無一時而不學,無一處而不學。........................................

吳怡迪 said...

廢話不多,祝你順心~^^........................................

R110926oseH said...

TAHNKS FOR YOUR SHARING~~~VERY NICE.................................................

函松 said...

hello~welcome my world~<. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

70713ang_eloknuth said...

keep update, please..bless you!!........................................

彥鈺璇洋 said...

TAHNKS FOR YOUR SHARING~~~VERY NICE ........................................

韋于倫成 said...

色情性愛片破解色情守門人成人色情電影院線上免費色情短片色情動畫影線上免費性愛小說甜心寶貝貼影區都都成人貼圖站都都成人網都都貼片區都都貼圖站都督成人貼圖都督情色網野求拳陰莖套陰道貼圖陰道遊戲最女優最性感美女遊戲最新av女優無碼都都成人貼片都都成人區都都成人往聊一夜情聊天,ut聊天男 聊天室聊天室男同志莉的遊戲處女免費小弟弟影片交流區 小弟弟影片區 貼圖區色情小遊戲

705RupertJ_Brobst0 said...

104成人 歐美色情視訊 聊天 85cc 豆豆交友 女優 美女裸照 免費做愛影片 熟女辣妹 ut南部聊天室 女同愛愛 情趣影片區 18禁 少女自衛 熊貓av影城 a片. 女女情色 免費色情片 一夜情 s383 情人視訊 玩美女人 日本美女影像 歐美辣妹 人妻 人妻熟女情慾 免費視訊 免費視訊 a圖 辣妹寫真 85cc 微風交友 live173 mvp7777.net 美眉貼圖 +援交留言版 情人視訊 免費台灣辣妹 成人片觀看 洪爺影城貼圖區 大奶美女影片 sex貼圖片 免費a片 美女巨乳 性感國中生 後宮電影院 20jack 限制級成人小說 色情0204 激情性愛照 歐美偷拍走光

慶天 said...

Wise men learn by other mens mistakes; fools by their own. ............................................................

estherme said...

Learning makes a good man better and ill man worse.............................................................

玫友 said...

世間是非,要如水泥地般水過則乾。..................................................................

彥霖 said...

休息才能再次出發-隨時保持好體力-加油.................................................................

原秋原秋 said...

知識可以傳授,智慧卻不行。每個人必須成為他自己。......................................................................

韋志韋志 said...

與人相處不妨多用眼睛說話,多用嘴巴思考,....................................................................

啟均 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

林嘉 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

育隆 said...

我來給你支持鼓勵~祝你事事如意~~..................................................................

PearleY建佑 said...

支持你就對了!..................................................................

雅莊王edgd春2蕙婷余惠其 said...

看到大家都留言-我也忍不住說聲---加油..................................................................

吳婷婷 said...

困難的不在於新概念,而在於逃避舊有的概念。............................................................

吳婷婷 said...

天氣涼了~要注意身體喔@~@...............................................................

彥安 said...

問聲好~~ 祝福您的blog愈來愈熱鬧!............................................................

錢靜怡錢靜怡錢靜怡 said...

聰明人之所以不會成功,是因為他們缺乏了堅忍的毅力。..................................................

淑娟淑娟淑娟 said...

喜歡這裡-支持你的更新............................................................

陳晏李秀樺雄 said...

人若賺得全世界,賠上自己的靈魂,有什麼益處?.......................................................

家唐銘 said...

喘口氣,看個文章,謝謝您的格子囉~~............................................................

家唐銘 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。............................................................

孟湖聿軒 said...

所有的資產,在不被諒解時,都成了負債.................................................................

校仪 said...

人不能像動物一樣活著,而應該追求知識和美德............................................................

凱v胡倫 said...

多謝美味的心靈雞湯......................................................

1615 said...

這不過是滑一跤,並不是死掉而爬不起來了。..................................................

孟謝謝謝凱謝謝謝謝 said...

出遊不拘名勝,有景就是好的..................................................................

牧宇 said...

在你一無所有的時候 是誰在陪伴你 他便是你最重要的人......................................................................

偉DimpleHolloway043昀 said...

上班好累哦,看看部落格轉換心情~~~先謝謝啦!!............................................................